After a team workshop, a team can start using Enneagram types to hand out jobs. This article explains why groups do this, using the group-dynamics idea of role fixation, how to tell it apart from a gap in the team's structure, and how to design the debrief and the follow-up so that type language opens people up, including a pause to use when it happens.
The problem: three months later
Three months after a workshop that the team lead called the most honest conversation the group had had in a year, the coach sits in on a planning meeting. A budget decision needs someone to challenge the head of finance. The team lead turns to one person: "You do it, you're our Eight." A few minutes later the quietest member of the team is asked whether they have a view, and a colleague answers for them, kindly: "Don't put them on the spot. That's just how Nines are."
Nothing in that meeting is hostile. The team is using what it learnt, warmly. It is also doing something the workshop never set out to teach: handing out jobs by type. One person now carries the confrontation for everyone else. Another has been excused from conflict, and with that excuse has lost a seat at the table.
The coach also notices what does not happen. Two people who had sharp views on the budget in the corridor beforehand stay silent, because the challenge has been delegated. (The team in this article is a composite.)
The technique in brief
To stop type labels from quietly turning into fixed roles:
- Before results are shared, agree with the team how type language will be used, and write the agreement down.
- At the first follow-up session, read the agreement back and say that you will name it when it happens, as anyone else may.
- Listen for a type being used to allocate a task, or to excuse someone from one.
- When it happens, do not correct anyone. Pause and ask the team whether type is the best reason they have, or the easiest one.
- Then ask the person who was given the role, or excused from it, whether they would want it if their type had nothing to do with it.
Why it happens: what groups do with roles
T. Martin Ringer, writing about groups in therapeutic, educational and corporate settings, lists role fixation among the defensive processes groups use to manage their own anxiety. Over time, each member narrows their range of behaviour to fit what the group has come to expect of them. In its extreme form, Ringer notes, this ends in scapegoating. Put plainly, the group finds it convenient for one person to hold the anger so that the rest do not have to.
Two further points in Ringer matter for team coaches.
Valency. This is Ringer's word for the pull each member brings towards certain patterns of relating. He also describes members gradually shaping each other's behaviour until their range narrows. Our reading of the two together is that a group finds the person most ready to play a part and then asks for more of it.
Roles can help. Ringer does not treat roles as a problem in themselves. Role differentiation is one measure of a group's maturity, and helpful roles can make a group more effective. The trouble starts when roles narrow people and nobody looks at the narrowing.
A team debrief can give role fixation a ready-made and very persuasive vocabulary. Before the workshop, the team had a vague sense that one colleague was "the difficult one". Afterwards it has a report and a facilitator's blessing. Valency helps explain why the label sticks: the colleague cast as the challenger probably does find confrontation easier than most.
The type did not create the role. It gave the team permission to stop asking anyone else, which is the use of type Kyra Ward warns about in Myth-busting the Enneagram Types: types used to box people, whatever is said against boxing.
Confirmation bias keeps the label in place: once someone is cast, we notice what fits and overlook what does not. Jamie Ziegler and Jim Ware's example is the "bad team player" label: we look for the misbehaviour and ignore the times that person played well. Every budget fight our team's Eight takes on confirms the casting. The corridor critics' objections, voiced where no decision is made, never count as challenge at all.
A gap in the structure, or a pattern in the group
Before treating every type-shaped role as a group defence, check a plainer explanation.
Peter Hawkins: confusion about the task. As a new team coach, Hawkins was often brought in to help teams understand each other's personality types and resolve conflict, and repeatedly found that the team's purpose, goals and roles were far from clear. No amount of process facilitation removed conflict that came from confusion about the task.
T. Martin Ringer: two kinds of informal role. Ringer's distinction points the same way:
- Roles that fill a gap in the formal structure. For example, the member who becomes timekeeper because the leader does not hold the time.
- Roles with unconscious causes. These appear whatever the structure says.
For our team the question is simple. Is it anyone's actual job to challenge the head of finance?
- If not, the team has a structural gap and has used a type label to fill it, and the Enneagram will not settle that.
- If someone already has that job and the team still turns to its Eight, the pattern is more likely the one Ringer describes.
Often both are at work. The iEQ9 Teams report can help with this conversation: it shows the team's dominant team style and how its members tend to handle conflict, so the discussion is about how the whole team handles challenge, not about its Eight.
The person who does not recognise the type
The clearest place to see role fixation at work is the team member who does not accept their result. Take the quiet colleague. In the one-to-one debrief before the team session, their report pointed to Type 9, and they were unsure. Some of it fitted; much did not. The coach, who ran the one-to-one debriefs as well as the team sessions, left it open and suggested a few weeks of noticing what rang true.
Then came the team workshop. The moment the type was shared, the team agreed, affectionately. "That's so you." Before the person had finished deciding what they thought, the group had decided for them.
The Learning Center gives practitioners two lenses for a client who does not resonate with their type:
- The 'Eek!' factor. A strong first reaction against the type, because the report holds up a mirror to fears and blind spots.
- A genuine mistype. The mistyping process is there to explore it.
The 'Eek!' material also reminds us that the test has not met the person, and that a type describes potential, not a person's reality. Both conversations depend on the client being free to reach their own conclusion. A one-to-one debrief protects that freedom. A team does not: a colleague's warm recognition carries social weight no report has, and the person may simply stop arguing.
Our reading is that this is role fixation in plain sight. The group has cast someone in a part before they have agreed to the script. The practitioner's task is a matter of ethics as much as craft. The type belongs to the person, and whether it fits is settled between them and the practitioner, never by a team vote.
Designing the debrief against it
None of this argues for keeping type out of team work. It argues for designing the session, and the months after it, so the language opens people up. These moves have helped us.
Ask what drives it
When someone describes a colleague's type by what that colleague does, ask what might be driving it, and let the colleague answer. Two Eights at different Levels of Integration can take the same budget challenge very differently, and only the person can say what the challenge costs them.
Use countertypes to break the picture
Countertypes are the most direct evidence a team can be given that one motivation can look close to opposite from the outside. In the Integrative Enneagram model, the Nine's countertype is the social subtype, which merges with the group through participation.
Our team's picture of a Nine was quiet. Shown that one Nine subtype is defined by taking part, the team lost its evidence: if quietness does not make someone a Nine, "that's so you" settles nothing.
The quiet colleague gained something too. The question of their type moved from "are you quiet enough?" to "what moves you?", which only they can answer, and which they could keep exploring without arguing with anyone.
Agree how the language will be used
Before results are shared, ask the team for an agreement:
"Over the next few months you will hear each other's types a lot. Can we agree that a type can explain why something is hard for someone, but never decides who does a task or who is let off one? And that anyone can say so when it happens?"
Write it down and bring it back at the follow-up. Make "I'm still testing mine" an ordinary thing to say in the room, too. Who sees individual results, and on what terms, is part of the same design question. The “Before the Questionnaire: Contracting an Enneagram Rollout” (for accredited practitioners) article, written for practitioners in organisational development, looks at that from the contracting side.
Try this: the pause
Set-up
- Open the first follow-up session by reading the written agreement back to the team.
- Say that you will name it when it happens, as anyone else may.
- Then listen for a type being used to allocate a task, or to excuse someone from one.
The team knows what you are listening for. The pause holds it to its own agreement.
The words
When it happens, do not correct anyone. Pause and ask the team:
"We agreed anyone could name this, so I'm naming it. We just gave that to someone because of their type. Is that the best reason we have, or the easiest one?"
Then turn to the person who was given the role, or excused from it:
"If your type had nothing to do with it, would you want this one?"
What goes wrong, and what to do then
The team hears a rebuke. Someone laughs and says, "We're only joking." Lower the stakes: "I know. Nobody did anything wrong. I'm curious whether the joke is quietly making decisions for us."
The person says they are happy with the role. Believe them, and widen the question: "Good. Then let's make sure it's a choice. Who backs you up when you push back?" A chosen role can still be shared.
The excused colleague freezes. Do not wait out the silence in front of the team. Offer a later route: "No need to answer now. Tell me or the team lead later if you'd like to." Spotlighting the person the team protects can repeat the very pattern you are naming.
The team lead is the one handing out roles. Raise it privately first: "When you asked for the challenge earlier, you named a type. I wonder whether the team heard that as permission to stop challenging."
You miss the moment. Bring it back before the session ends: "Earlier, when the budget came up, we went straight to one person. I'd like to go back to that for two minutes."
What happened with our team
Before the follow-up, the coach raised the lead's "you're our Eight" in private. At the follow-up itself, the budget came round again and heads turned to the same person. The coach paused.
The team member cast as the challenger laughed, then admitted that going into every fight had become tiring, and that the others now seemed to wait for it. One of the corridor critics spoke on the budget in the room for the first time.
The quiet colleague said nothing in the session, and emailed the team lead a detailed critique of the proposal that evening, after the decision had been taken. The view had been there all along, and the follow-up had not made room for it either. The team lead's answer was a change to how the team works, not to the colleague: proposals now go out a day ahead, and written comments are read before the discussion starts.
Afterwards the coach had a private word with the quiet colleague:
"Your result is yours to test, at your own pace. The team does not get a vote."
The challenger's role went less tidily. At the next session the team agreed that the corridor critic would lead the next conversation with finance, with the challenger in support. That happened once.
By the following quarter the team was turning to its Eight again, and the Eight said, with apparent ease, that they were happy to do it. The coach asked who backed them up, and two names came quickly. Whether the role is now a choice, or the old pattern with better manners, the coach still does not know.
In the next one-to-one the quiet colleague and the coach returned to the report. The person is still testing it. A free conclusion can take that long.
Variations for different settings
Teams you see occasionally or online
If you see a team once a quarter, you will not catch the moment live. Ask two or three members to note one time in the weeks before your session when a type was used to hand out a task. Open with those examples, without names, and use the same two questions. On a video call the shortcut often appears in the chat instead ("over to our Eight!"), so read the chat, give people time to unmute, and accept written answers.
Internal practitioners
An HR or L&D practitioner inside the organisation has relationships, and sometimes reporting lines, with the people in the room. Contract for the pause explicitly with the team lead, and lean on the written agreement, so the challenge comes from what the team agreed rather than from your position.
Where this stops working
An observation, not a finding. The link between type labels and role fixation comes from our practice, and nobody has measured how often it happens.
Overcorrection. Once the agreement is in place, some teams stop using the type language at all, for fear of breaking it. Then return to motivation. The aim was never silence about type.
Scapegoating. This is the extreme end of role fixation in Ringer's account, and a boundary for the pause. If a team member is being blamed or shut out, that is no longer a debrief design issue. It may be a matter for the sponsor or HR under the coaching contract, and the person may need support that coaching cannot give. Say where coaching ends rather than reach for a clever question.
Gaps in the structure. Here the pause will expose the gap, but the team, often with its sponsor, has to close it.
The question we are still holding
Some role differentiation is healthy; Ringer treats it as a sign of a maturing group. Teams do need someone to ask the hard question, and a person who is good at it may welcome the job. Our challenger may be an example, or may not. The difficulty is telling a differentiated role, which a person has chosen and the team shares, from a fixed one the group has found it convenient to give them, especially when the person says they are happy with it. We are not sure the coach can always tell from the outside. How do you judge, in a team you work with over months, when a type-shaped role has stopped serving the person who carries it?
Sources
- T. Martin Ringer, Group Action: The Dynamics of Groups in Therapeutic, Educational and Corporate Settings (Jessica Kingsley Publishers, 2002), pp. 100, 107, 153 (table 7.2) and 253, drawing on Bion (1961), Wells (1995), Guetzkow (1953) and Colman (1995).
- Jamie Ziegler and Jim Ware, with Liz Severyns, Type, Talent and Teams: Using the Enneagram for Investment Firm Success (CreateSpace, 2018), chapter 5.
- Peter Hawkins, Leadership Team Coaching: Developing Collective Transformational Leadership, 4th edition (Kogan Page, 2021), pp. 48–49.
- Integrative Enneagram Solutions, Learning Center Module 2: "The 'Eek!' factor when discovering your Type", "Difficulties that result from typing clients" and "Revisiting the 27 Subtypes and Countertypes"; Module 14: "Deep Dive Enneagram 9".
- Kyra Ward, Myth-busting the Enneagram Types (Integrative Enneagram Solutions, 2019).
What is the Enneagram?
Introduction to the 27 Subtypes
Introduction to the 3 Centers
Wings
Lines and Integration
Enneagram History & Origin
International Enneagram Conference